EXCERPTS -- UNOFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
U.S. Assistant Secretary of State, Richard A. Boucher
On Camera Panel-interview with Pakistani Television Media
June 15, 2007
(Begin Excerpts)
QUESTION: Thank you very much for inviting us here and having the time for us. President Musharraf has been saying that he will decide about his uniform issue as per the Constitution of Pakistan. Two days back, the State Department Spokesman expressed his belief that General/President Musharraf will remove his uniform and he will get re-elected from the next assemblies. What formed the basis of that belief in the State Department? Is their some assurance from President Musharraf or this is your own democratic aspirations?
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: I think, first of all, that there is the assurance that you cited in your question, that the President has said he would deal with this matter of two jobs in accordance to the Constitution as part of the election process. We take him at his word that he will do that. So, we're repeating what we've already heard and said. That is, that the President has said he will deal with this matter in accordance with the Constitution as part of the elections.
As far as how the scenario unfolds this fall, I think our Spokesman also noted that there were different scenarios and I guess we'll see what happens. But to a great extent, how the election happens, how a new election happens, is up to the Pakistani people. Our interest is in seeing an election that is free and fair and that gives a choice to the Pakistani people, where the Pakistani people can really choose who their leadership is going to be.
QUESTION: Ambassador Boucher, this is a question about the bigger picture. A section of Pakistani public opinion, one that a visitor to the country may not often get to meet directly because this section of the public opinion is not affiliated with any of the political parties, opposition, or government. This section believes that
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: I think that the prevalent viewpoint in the U.S. Government, that is really mirrored by a lot of opinion I meet here, not just some specific section but a lot of different people, is that it's time for
Just the other day, he reversed some regulations against the press and reaffirmed the need for a free press. Those are all things that we support and we're frankly happy to work with the government, we're happy to work with the Pakistani people as a whole, to help the country move in that direction. That's our goal too: to help
QUESTION: My question is the role of
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: Well, I think first of all there are a lot of different statements in the
We certainly recognize the enormous effort, the enormous achievements and the enormous sacrifices that
At the same time, we're not done with this. We have a job to do in
QUESTION: Mr. Boucher, there are media reports that you are for mediating a deal between President Musharraf and the Pakistan People's Party. Is it a true story?
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: You know, I think I've come here about nine times since I took this job fourteen months ago, so I'm here on a very regular basis. And I know every time I come there's some speculation that I'm going to get involved in the most recent crisis or issue. I see my visits much more as a regular process of discussions between the two countries, strategic discussions between the two countries, discussions on the region, on what's going on in
Obviously, we're interested in the political situation. I've had a chance to talk to a whole variety of people during my meetings and also at the reception the other night when all the political parties were there. So, yeah, we talk about politics, and I hear about politics. I'm interested in political developments. I think as far as our role in that, ultimately the politics is going to work itself out in
But to the extent that we can encourage the parties to sort of move together, create a stronger moderate center, we do that and we think that's part of the overall direction of the country. We think that the parties need to look for their common interest, need to look for how to stabilize the center of Pakistani politics. And when we meet with leaders of the parties we make that view known. But that's encouragement to sort of move forward in a moderate and stable direction and we do that with everything.
QUESTION: Mr. Assistant Secretary of State, you rightly said that you were interested in politics, but coming back to the question which I was asking from you, that well, there could be some assurance as you have just spoken from President Musharraf but here in the domestic scenario, he has never made a categorical statement that he will remove the uniform.
Do you feel that his assurances include that he will remove the uniform? Or do you believe that retaining the uniform will provide some chance of free, fair and transparent elections in this country?
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: The answer is no. I don't believe either one of those things. I don't believe that the whole issue of the election rises or falls on whether or not or when President Musharraf carries out whatever is appropriate under the Constitution with regard to his two jobs. The issue of a free and fair election is much more fundamental than that. We've been here supporting the right of the Pakistani people to choose. We've been supporting the work of the Election Commission. We've been talking to the parties.
You know, the other night, all the party leaders were talking about an all-party conference to get all the parties together and agree on how to get to a free and fair election and what are the elements of that. Whether this comes into it or not, you know, could be a subject for their discussion, but I think that the issue of the election is much broader. We support an election process that is free and fair and gives the Pakistani people the right to choose, and it's not going to hang on one particular question. That particular question needs to be answered but I think we have a bit of patience in seeing it answered at whatever is the appropriate time.
QUESTION: You visited the Chaman border point between
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: First of all, let me say I had a very interesting day yesterday. I want to thank everybody who was a host to me then in
I think, you know, we're talking about my visits and I remember being here in January when that was introduced and you're right, the reaction on the Afghan side was not positive, should we say. There were demonstrations and other things. Our hope is that some of these things can be worked out. One of the things I've done in all my meetings here and in my meetings with Afghans recently is to say where, how many different matters can
Those kind of political discussions need to keep going. Issues like border crossings are naturals. And somehow
QUESTION: But do you think it's a good system?
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: I think it's a great system. Whether it works for both sides or not, that's something that those sides are going to have to sit down and talk about. But in terms of Pakistan and that particular point, where they have so many people going across to the market in the morning and coming back in the afternoon, that having a quick way of identifying the known people, is very important. Because then you can concentrate your efforts on the unknown people. And that's where your problems are going to be.
So, I think it's a great system for that location and given that kind of transit trade. If it works for both sides, maybe we can get both sides to use it. If not, at least if the sides start to sit down and work on cross-border movement, maybe they can figure out some other things that work.
QUESTION: Mr. Boucher, after 9/11, the
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: Absolutely not. And I think if you look at what we're doing, look at what we're doing in
Basically, people need a lot of things from their government and we have to be sure government can give them that. Government has to extend itself and it has to deliver what the people need. They want safety, they want justice, they want opportunity. And opportunity comes about when you have a road and you have electricity and you have an irrigation system. And they want a chance to decide their futures. And that is, elections, democracy and a role in government. So if you look at what people need, that's what you have to give them to stabilize these regions. And I think that, frankly, that's the approach the Pakistani government is taking as well with regard to the tribal areas, the border areas.
You all know the history of these areas better than I do. But they haven't been governed under normal arrangements since history (began). And so as we move forward, we also need to develop these areas, give these people a stake in the national economy, give them opportunities. So, we're supporting a sustainable development plan for the tribal areas that's going to be a significant investment for the Pakistani government, but also we're going to make sure that there's 750 million dollars available from the
QUESTION: Mr. Boucher, the
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: Well, we've been one of the largest democracies for 200 and some years. Our goal is to support democracy and movement towards democracy wherever it appears, to give the people that are struggling, that are fighting, that are moving forward to democracy all the support that we can. In
QUESTION: Let me come to follow up to initiatives of President Bush's visit to
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: Well, I think we're doing better than you give us credit for. But you're right, we have an agenda coming from President Bush's visit, from the meetings at that time with President Musharraf and we do follow up very carefully on that agenda. That's one of the things I did this time and I've done on previous visits with the Foreign Ministry. We have had a series of discussions, we had a Strategic Dialogue last year, we've had an economic meeting, we've had the Education Dialogue, we've had science and technology meetings, we've had a number of energy meetings, more than the high-level meetings, we've had some very specific ones on new technologies and cooperation in those areas. And so we're going through a whole strategic agenda, the whole complete agenda.
We have many programs here. You know, this is the largest Fulbright Program, exchange program, that we have anywhere in the world, and that is going great guns. And there are more scholars this year than last year. So these things are going forward that have been announced.
We haven't had the formal Strategic Dialogue. But again, I have to say, every time we have a visitor - me, Secretary Gates, our Deputy Secretary of State who is going to come in and have discussions here for the next two days as part of the regular consultations - those are strategic level discussions between the
Reconstruction Zones are going forward. We said at the time it was going to take a little while to get it going. We've done the economic studies to identify real economic potential for the zones. We've now been working to craft the legislation. And I think we're very close to the point where we'll have something to submit to our Congress. So, it's a lot of in-house work to get that ready; it's a very complicated economic matter. But it's pretty much on schedule, maybe a little bit slower than we would have hoped, but it's pretty much on schedule and moving forward even though most of the work so far has been in-house work and hasn't had much of the public impression.
QUESTION: Ambassador Boucher, this is more like more of a personal question. Often when you come here, I'm fascinated by the way often opposition politicians or local politicians in the provinces come up to you and draw your attention to very local provincial politics. For example, yesterday you were in Quetta and one of the politicians there, who happened to be from the opposition, drew your attention to problems in his province, 'the government is not consulting us on major project' and other things, you know, very local political issues and I think he forwarded to you a complaint against the federal government of Pakistan regarding that, and you accepted that letter. So I'm just fascinated, I mean, when you do this, when you accept this, what do you feel, I mean? Do you, for example, give them a sign that you would help in this or get involved in that kind of local politics? What's your feeling on a personal level?
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: Well, I think first of all, I try not to be, a Pakistani. I'm not part of the political process here. It's not my job to carry messages inside the country or to advocate a point of view inside the country. You know, I'm an outsider, and so my interest is in sort of, what's going on around here. How does this affect the development of the country, how does this affect the stability of the country, how does it affect our ability to work together on things that are important?
So, I suppose politicians talk to us for a variety of reasons. One is that's what politicians do and that's what we do. So we fit together pretty well they talk, we listen, it's always interesting. Second of all, we're always looking for people to support their cause. And third, if you want to have an understanding of what's going on in
And second of all, this whole - you know, you say, national development projects are a local issue, but when we look at the strategic approach from Pakistan and the strategic goal of Pakistan in regard to the corridors to Central Asia, the opportunities that we see, and that Pakistan sees, that Afghanistan sees, for more trade and transit through Afghanistan down to the ports of Pakistan and beyond. The port of Gwadar, the road links, the transportation links, how they're handled, how they're supported by the local population, that's a key element of the strategic picture.
And so, these things sometimes look local but when I look at them, I tend to see them as part of a big strategic position of
QUESTION: Mr. Boucher, my question is about Pak-India relations and the
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: I think we've played a role as best we can. We are very interested in seeing progress between
Our job I think is to encourage progress. And every time we talk to either
We recognize that movement in
QUESTION: Mr. Boucher, during your stay here you met political parties, leadership from political parties and other people around. Do you, are you satisfied with the political condition in
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: I think, I hear a lot from the political party leaders and have over time here and elsewhere, about the prospects for the elections. I emphasize again and again our desires to see free and fair elections, to give the people of
Some of it's political. Some of it's fundamental though - things like having voter lists, things like having the voter lists available for people to check, political parties to check, trying to see if they can't be made available in electronic form. I think that would be a good idea. Having a stronger, more independent Election Commission. Tat was one of the reasons why I went to see the Election Commission. Making sure that the parties and anybody else just stays out of the process once the voters go to vote.
There are a lot of fundamental issues. Our interest is in the process of democracy. We support it with money, we support it with expertise, we support it with observers. We've seen a lot of examples from around the world, so we try to be very active. But our interest is in seeing the process develop freely and fairly. And we'll work with the parties, we'll work the Election Commission, we'll work with everybody to try to see that that happens.
QUESTION: Excellency, as my friend pointed out, the regional peace. There is a very important project called Iran-Pakistan-India gas pipeline. We know that the European countries, they are having good relations with
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: Well, I think there are a couple of factors at work here and we've expressed - you're right, we've expressed our skepticism about the project. We've expressed our reservations about the project. That's the way I'd put it. And let me tell you why.
First of all, I don't think you can separate
So, you have to look at you bigger interests in all these things. You have to look at the issues of terrorism, you have to look at the issues of
Second of all, I don't know that you want to tie your gas supply to
But, you know, energy supply for
QUESTION: About
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: Well, I think two things. One, on missile defense, the developments were sort of interesting last week because
As far as U.S.-Russian cooperation in
We're supporting regional trade developments because it's one thing to build roads and electric lines, and we're doing all that, but at the same time, you need to make sure the border posts operate smoothly, we need an end to bribery, change the trucking regulations, whatever else it takes for the vegetables to flow, or the goods to flow, or ideas to flow. So, we are working in a regional context and we do hope to work with
QUESTION: But the fact, Mr. Ambassador, would you be open to the idea of the Russians, that the one that the Russians are proposing, the using of the radar in
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: In many ways, that question goes beyond my personal competence and I haven't seen any studies. Part of it's technical, would it work, and part of it's what's the most economic and efficient way to organize this system. But I think we, NATO, European countries have said we ought to sit down with the Russians and talk about this.
QUESTION: Mr. Boucher, after this latest legislation by the U.S. Congress about
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: Which latest legislation?
QUESTION: Legislations that U.S President Bush, will, the President will provide a certificate about
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: You have to remember that it hasn't passed. That's not legislation; that's not a bill; that's not an act of law. That was a bill passed by one side of our legislature, the House. The Senate didn't have that provision and they have to get together to work it out. So, we'll see what ultimately emerges from the Congress. We have been opposed to that provision. We've made that very clear on the record. I have taken it up with people on the Hill. Others in the administration, the White House, senior levels of the State Department, have objected to that provision. So it may never become law. It may change or be dropped by the time final legislation is prepared.
As far as you more basic question, what's the status of the F-16 bill - right on track. It's going forward fine, won't be affected, we intend to proceed with it. It's an important commitment, it's an important area of cooperation.
QUESTION: The government of
ASSISTANT SECRETARY BOUCHER: Well, first of all, I think we do support the refugees going back home. When it comes down to it, people want to be home and they want to be able to live safely and securely at home. And so, part of it is the conditions in
(End Excerpts)
# # #
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(For more press releases, please visit our website: http://islamabad.usembassy.gov)
-----------------------------------------------------------
N A D E E M M A L I K
CNBC PAKISTAN
BUREAU CHIEF
ISLAMABAD
0321-5117511
16th Floor,
FREE pop-up blocking with the new MSN Toolbar MSN Toolbar Get it now!