Nadeem Malik

Wednesday, December 31, 2008

TERROR RELATED CASUALTIES IN PAKISTAN 2003-08

Casualties of Terrorist Violence in Pakistan

Annual Fatalities in Terrorist Violence in Pakistan, 2003-2008


Civilians
Security Force Personnel
Terrorists/Insurgents
Total

2003

140
24
25
189

2004

435
184
244
863
2005
430
81
137
648
2006
608
325
538
1471
2007
1523
597
1479
3599
2008*
2049
646
3875
6570

Total

5282
1833
6305
13648
* Data till December 22, 2008

Year 2008

 
Civilians
Security Force Personnel
Terrorists/Insurgents
Total
January
88
111
455
654
February
182
33
30
245
March
137
26
41
204
April
80
25
16
121
May
61
30
37
128
June
149
31
38
218
July
82
71
250
403
August
339
124
784
1247
September
272
67
876
1215
October
262
60
735
1057
November
225
50
482
757
December*
172
18
131
321
Total
2049
646
3875
6570
* Data till December 22, 2008
Source: Figures are compiled from news reports and are provisional.

Year 2007

 
Civilians
Security Force Personnel
Terrorists/Insurgents
Total
January
26
16
29
71
February
35
4
8
47
March
28
21
261
310
April
176
18
83
277
May
57
10
14
81
June
31
12
40
83
July
144
143
191
478
August
56
63
117
236
September
101
67
144
312
October
282
101
154
537
November
293
94
341
728
December
293
48
97
438
Total
1523
597
1479
3599
Source: Figures are compiled from news reports and are provisional.


Year 2006

 
Civilians
Security Force Personnel
Terrorists
Total
January
114
29
22
165
February
88
16
2
106
March
91
19
221
331
April
96
44
53
193
May
43
39
5
87
June
26
29
47
102
July
12
52
49
113
August
22
43
44
109
September
22
0
2
24
October
42
7
83
132
November
42
45
9
91
December
10
2
1
13
Total
608
325
538
1471



Year 2005

 
Civilians
Security Force Personnel
Terrorists
Total
January
30
7
2
39
February
11
0
6
17
March
77
15
3
95
April
6
2
2
10
May
63
5
2
70
June
8
1
0
9
July
29
2
43
74
August
14
10
1
25
September
32
17
40
89
October
27
15
16
58
November
13
0
12
25
December
120
7
10
137
Total
430
81
137
648

Year 2004

 
Civilians
Security Force Personnel
Terrorists
Total
January
0
4
0
4
February
2
0
1
3
March
47
45
25
117
April
6
5
1
12
May
45
0
0
45
June
60
37
24
121
July
28
6
19
53
August
42
17
4
63
September
70
36
70
176
October
114
11
28
153
November
5
19
72
96
December
16
4
0
20
Total
435
184
244
863


 
Year 2003

 
Civilians
Security Force Personnel
Terrorists
Total
January
7
0
0
7
February
18
3
1
22
March
0
0
1
1
April
1
0
0
1
May
6
0
1
7
June
5
13
0
18
July
61
2
0
63
August
4
0
0
4
September
10
0
0
10
October
8
5
18
31
November
0
0
2
2
December
20
1
2
23
Total
140
24
25
189

 


 
 
-----------------------------------------------------------
N A D E E M   M A L I K
Director Programme
AAJ TV
ISLAMABAD
00-92-321-5117511

nadeem.malik@hotmail.com 




check out the rest of the Windows Live™. More than mail–Windows Live™ goes way beyond your inbox. More than messages

Why the CIA does not want Dawood in Indian hands


 

Why the CIA does not want Dawood in Indian hands

 

 

 

December 22, 2008
The role Dawood Ibrahim [Images], the underworld kingpin who heads the D-Company and has known ties to Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence and even the Central Intelligence Agency, is apparently being whitewashed. His capture and handover to India might prove inconvenient for either the ISI or the CIA, or both.

It was Ibrahim who was initially characterised by press reports as being the mastermind behind the attacks. Now, that title is being given to Zaki-ur Rehman Lakhvi by numerous media accounts reporting that Pakistan security forces have raided a training camp of the group Lashkar-e-Tayiba [Images], which evidence has indicated was behind the attacks. Lakhvi was reportedly captured in the raid and is now in custody.

At the same time Ibrahim's role is being downplayed, Lakhvi's known role is being exaggerated. Initial reports described him as the training specialist for LeT, but the major media outlets like the New York Times and the London [Images] Times, citing government sources, have since promoted his status to that of commander of operations for the group.

The only terrorist from the Mumbai attacks to be captured alive, Ajmal Amir Kasab [Images], characterised Ibrahim, not Lakhvi, as the mastermind of those attacks, according to earlier press accounts.

Kasab reportedly told his interrogators that he and his fellow terrorists were trained under Lakhvi, also known as Chacha (uncle), at a camp in Pakistan. Indian officials also traced calls from a satellite phone used by the terrorists to Lakhvi.

But the phone had also been used to call Yusuf Muzammil, also known as Abu Yusuf, Abu Hurrera, and "Yahah". And it has been Muzammil, not Lakhvi, who has previously been described as the military commander of the LeT. It was an intercepted call to Muzammil on November 18 that put the Indian Navy and Coast Guard on high alert to be on the lookout for any foreign vessels from Pakistan entering Indian waters.

Kasab told his interrogators that his team had set out from Karachi, Pakistan, on a ship belonging to Dawood Ibrahim, the MV Alpha. They then hijacked an Indian fishing trawler, the Kuber, to pass through Indian territorial waters to elude the Navy and Coast Guard that were boarding and searching suspect ships.

Although the MV Alpha was subsequently found and seized by the Indian Navy, there have been few, if any, developments about this aspect of the investigation in press accounts, such as whether it has been confirmed or not that the ship was owned by Ibrahim.

Upon arriving off the coast near the city, they were received by inflatable rubber dinghies that had been arranged by an associate of Ibrahim's in Mumbai.

The planning and execution of the attacks are indicative of the mastermind role not of either Lakhvi or Muzammil, but of Ibrahim, an Indian who is intimately familiar with the city. It was in Mumbai that Ibrahim rose through the ranks of the underworld to become a major organised crime boss.

At least two other Indians were also connected to the attacks, Mukhtar Ahmed and Tausef Rahman. They were arrested for their role in obtaining SIM cards used in the cell phones of the terrorists. Ahmed, according to Indian officials, had in fact been recruited by a special counter-insurgency police task force as an undercover operative. His exact role is still being investigated.

One of the SIM cards used was possibly purchased from New Jersey. Investigators are looking into this potential link to the US, as well.

Dawood Ibrahim went from underworld kingpin to terrorist in 1993, when he was connected to a series of bombings in Mumbai that resulted in 250 deaths. He is wanted by Interpol and was designated by the US as a global terrorist in 2003.

It Is believed Ibrahim has been residing in Karachi, and Indian officials have accused Pakistan's ISI of protecting him.

Ibrahim is known to be a major drug trafficker responsible for shipping narcotics into the United Kingdom and Western Europe.

According to the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, most Afghan opium (or its derivative, heroin, which is increasingly being produced in the country before export) is smuggled through Iran and Turkey en route by land to Europe; but the percentage that goes to Pakistan seems to mostly find its way directly to the UK, either by plane or by ship.

Afghanistan is the world's leading producer of opium, a trend that developed during the CIA-backed mujahedeen effort to oust the Soviet Union from the country, with the drug trade serving to help finance the war.

A known drug trafficker, Dawood Ibrahim is naturally also involved in money laundering, which is perhaps where the role of gambling operations in Nepal comes into the picture.

Yoichi Shimatsu, former editor of the Japan [Images] Times, wrote last month after the Mumbai attacks that Ibrahim had worked with the US to help finance the mujahedeen during the 1980s and that because he knows too much about the US's 'darker secrets' in the region, he could never be allowed to be turned over to India.

The recent promotion of Lakhvi to 'mastermind' of the attacks while Ibrahim's name disappears from media reports would seem to lend credence to Shimatsu's assertion.

Investigative journalist Wayne Madsen similarly reported that according to intelligence sources, Ibrahim is a CIA asset, both as a veteran of the mujahedeen war and in a continuing connection with his casino and drug trade operations in Kathmandu, Nepal. A deal had been made earlier this year to have Pakistan hand Ibrahim over to India, but the CIA was fearful that this would lead to too many of its dirty secrets coming to light, including the criminal activities of high level personnel within the agency.

One theory on the Mumbai attacks is that it was backlash for this double-cross that was among other things intended to serve as a warning that any such arrangement could have further serious consequences.

Although designated as a major international terrorist by the US, media reports in India have characterised the US's past interest in seeing Ibrahim handed over as less than enthusiastic. Former Indian deputy prime minister L K Advani [Images] wrote in his memoir, My Country, My Life, that he made a great effort to get Pakistan to hand over Ibrahim, and met with then US secretary of state Colin Powell and then national security advisor Condoleezza Rice [Images] (now secretary of state) to pressure Pakistan to do so. But he was informed by Powell that Pakistan would hand over Ibrahim only "with some strings attached" and that then Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf [Images] would need more time before doing so.

The handover, needless to say, never occurred. The Pakistan government has also publicly denied that Ibrahim is even in the country; a denial that was repeated following the recent Mumbai attacks.

Others suspected of involvement in the attacks and named among the 20 individuals India wants Pakistan to turn over also have possible connections to the CIA, including Hafiz Mohammad Saeed, the founder of LeT, and Jaish-e-Mohammed leader Maulana Masood Azhar, both veterans of the CIA-backed mujahedeen effort.

Azhar had been captured in 1994 and imprisoned in India for his role as leader of the Pakistani-based terrorist group Harkut-ul-Mujahideen. He was released, however, in 1999 in exchange for hostages from the takeover of Indian Airlines Flight 814, which was hijacked during its flight from Kathmandu, Nepal to Delhi [Images], India and redirected to Afghanistan. After Azhar's release, he formed JeM, which was responsible for an attack on the Indian Parliament in 2001 that led Pakistan and India to the brink of war. LeT was also blamed for the attack alongside JeM.

Both LeT and JeM have links to the ISI, which has used the groups as proxies in the conflict with India over the territory of Kashmir.

Saeed travelled to Peshawar to join the mujahedeen cause during the Soviet-Afghan war. Peshawar served as the base of operations for the CIA, which worked closely with the ISI to finance, arm, and train the mujahedeen. It was in Peshawar that Saeed became the protege of Abdullah Azzam, who founded an organization called Maktab al-Khidamat along with a Saudi individual named Osama bin Laden [Images].

MaK worked alongside the CIA-ISI operations to recruit Arabs to the ranks of the mujahedeen. The ISI, acting as proxy for the CIA, chose mainly to channel its support to Afghans, such as warlord Gulbaddin Hekmatyar. The US claims the CIA had no relationship with MaK, but bin Laden's operation, which later evolved into Al Qaeda [Images], must certainly have been known to, and approved by, the CIA.

But there are indications that the CIA's relationship with MaK and Al Qaeda go well beyond having shared a common enemy and mutual interests in the Soviet-Afghan war. A number of Al Qaeda associates appear to have been protected individuals.

Another former head of the ISI is now being privately accused by the US of involvement with the group responsible for the Mumbai attacks, according to reports citing a document listing former ISI chief Lieutenant General Hamid Gul and four other former heads of Pakistan's intelligence agency as being involved in supporting terrorist networks. The individuals named have been recommended to the UN Security Council to be named as international terrorists, according to Pakistan's The News.

The document has been provided to the Pakistan government and also accuses Gul, who was head of the ISI from 1987 to 1989, of providing assistance to criminal groups in Kabul, as well as to groups responsible for recruiting and training militants to attack US-led forces in Afghanistan, including the Taliban [Images].

Hamid Gul responded to the reports by calling the allegations hilarious. The US denied that it had made any such recommendations to the UN.

But the US has similarly accused the ISI of involvement in the bombing of India's embassy in Kabul last July. This was unusual not because of the allegation of an ISI connection to terrorism but because it was in such stark contrast with US attempts to publicly portray Pakistan as a staunch ally in its 'war on terrorism' when the country was under the dictatorship of Musharraf.

The US attitude toward Pakistan shifted once an elected government came to power that has been more willing to side with the overwhelming belief among the public that it is the 'war on terrorism' itself that has exacerbated the problem of extremist militant groups and led to further terrorist attacks within the country, such as the assassination of former prime minister Benazir Bhutto [Images] last year or the bombing of the Marriot Hotel in September. While the world's attention has been focused on the attacks in Mumbai, a bomb blast in Peshawar killed 21 and injured 90.

While the purported US document names Gul and others as terrorist supporters, another report, from Indian intelligence, indicates that the terrorists who carried out the attacks in Mumbai were among 500 trained by instructors from the Pakistan military, according to The Times. This training of the 10 known Mumbai terrorists would have taken place prior to their recent preparation for these specific attacks by the LeT training specialist Zaki-ur Rehman Lakhvi.

But while Lakhvi, Muzammil, and Hafiz Saeed [Images] have continued to be named in connection with last month's attacks in Mumbai, the name of Dawood Ibrahim seems to be either disappearing altogether or his originally designated role as the accused mastermind of the attacks being credited now instead to Lakhvi in media accounts.

Whether this is a deliberate effort to downplay Ibrahim's role in the attacks so as not to have to force Pakistan to turn him over because of embarrassing revelations pertaining to the CIA's involvement with known terrorists and drug traffickers that development could possibly produce isn't certain.

But what is certain is that the CIA has had a long history of involvement with such characters and that the US has a track record of attempting to keep information about the nature of such involvement in the dark or to cover it up once it reaches the light of public scrutiny.

Jeremy R Hammond is the editor of Foreign Policy Journal. Reproduced with kind courtesy of Foreign Policy Journal.

 


 
 
-----------------------------------------------------------
N A D E E M   M A L I K
Director Programme
AAJ TV
ISLAMABAD
00-92-321-5117511

nadeem.malik@hotmail.com 




Add maps and directions to your party Show them the way!

Pakistan March 9, 2007 to end-2008

Musharraf suspends chief justice
Pakistani President Gen. Pervez Musharraf suspends Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry on allegations of misconduct. Pakistani lawyers take to the streets in droves to protest the move.
   May 2007
Hotel bomb blast kills 24
A bomb blast tied to rallies over Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry's suspension kills 24 in Peshawar.
   July 10, 2007
Pakistani security forces storm Islamabad's Red Mosque
After a week-long siege, Pakistani security forces storm Islamabad's Red Mosque, attacking alleged al-Qaida militants inside. Nearly 100 people are killed in the raid.
   July 20, 2007
Supreme Court reinstates Chaudhry
The Pakistani Supreme Court reinstates Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry.
   July 27, 2007
Musharraf meets with Bhutto
Exiled former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto meets with President Pervez Musharraf in Abu Dhabi to talk about a possible power-sharing deal.
   Sept. 10, 2007
Sharif returns from exile, is expelled
Exiled former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif returns to Pakistan only to be arrested upon landing at Islamabad Airport and sent back to Saudi Arabia.
   October 2007
Musharraf wins re-election
President Pervez Musharraf wins the majority vote in the presidential election on Oct. 6, but the Supreme Court asserts that no winner can be announced until it decides if the president can be a standing army chief.
Benazir Bhutto returns from exile Oct. 18. A suicide bomber targeting her convoy kills more than 100 people, though she escapes the attack unharmed.
   November 2007
Musharraf declares state of emergency
President Gen. Pervez Musharraf declares a state of emergency on Nov. 3 to clamp down on growing anti-government protests. While awaiting the verdict from the Supreme Court on whether his candidacy was legitimate, Musharraf again removes Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry. A reshaped Supreme Court later dismisses the challenges to his presidency. Under intense political pressure, Musharraf resigns his military post on Nov. 29 and pledges to end emergency rule.
   December 2007
Emergency rule ends; Bhutto assassinated
Now civilian President Pervez Musharraf follows through with his pledge to end emergency rule, moving on Dec. 15 to rescind his order. On Dec. 29, a suicide attacker kills opposition leader Benazir Bhutto as she campaigned ahead of critical parliamentary elections set for early 2008.
   February 2008
Opposition parties win in parliamentary elections
The Pakistan Peoples Party wins the most seats in parliamentary elections and soon forms an alliance with Pakistan Muslim League-N to seek the reinstatement of judges fired by Musharraf and to reduce his powers.
   August 2008
Musharraf resigns
Facing growing pressure from Pakistan's Parliament and the threat of impeachment, Musharraf announces on Aug. 18 that he will step down as president.
   September 2008
Zardari elected
Asif Ali Zardari, the widower of former premier Benazir Bhutto and leader of the Pakistan People's Party, was elected Sept. 6 as president of Pakistan.


 
 
-----------------------------------------------------------
N A D E E M   M A L I K
Director Programme
AAJ TV
ISLAMABAD
00-92-321-5117511

nadeem.malik@hotmail.com 




check out the rest of the Windows Live™. More than mail–Windows Live™ goes way beyond your inbox. More than messages

NADEEM MALIK LIVE

NADEEM MALIK LIVE

Nadeem Malik Live is the flagship current affairs programme of Pakistan. The programme gives independent news analysis of the key events shaping future of Pakistan. A fast paced, well rounded programme covers almost every aspect, which should be a core element of a current affairs programme. Discussion with the most influential personalities in the federal capital and other leading lights of the country provides something to audience to help them come out with their own hard hitting opinions.

http://youtube.com/NadeemMalikLive